Home › Articles › Avoid These 10 Costly Mista...

Avoid These 10 Costly Mistakes When Selling Your Car

Selling a car can be a straightforward process if done correctly, but many people fall into common traps that can cost them time, money, legal liability and peace of mind. Here are some key mistakes to avoid when selling your car:

1. Neglecting Proper Documentation

One of the biggest mistakes sellers make is not having all the necessary paperwork needed to complete the sale correctly. This includes the car's title, maintenance records, and any loan payoff information. Without these, you might face delays, personal risk and even legal issues. Ensure you have the title in your name and free of liens before listing your car for sale. Once you sell your car, never ever sign over (assign) the title without completing all buyer (purchaser) personal information based on their current driver license or photo ID. This is commonly referred to as, "selling on an open title," and it enables the buyer to partake in a harmful practice called "curbstoning." No matter what reason or excuse a buyer uses for asking you to leave the purchaser information blank on the title assignment field, your answer should always be "No" even if it means losing the sale.

2. Setting an Unrealistic Price

Overpricing your car can lead to it sitting on the market for too long, while underpricing means you could lose money. Research your car’s market value using tools like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds, and consider factors such as mileage, condition, and local demand. Being realistic about your car's value will attract serious buyers and facilitate a quicker sale.

3. Skimping on Cleaning, Maintenance and Repairs

First impressions matter. A clean, well-maintained car is much more appealing to buyers. Invest in a thorough, professional cleaning, both inside and out, and take care of minor repairs and maintenance items that could be buyer distractions. This can significantly increase your car’s appeal and potentially its sale price. Buyers often perceive clean, well-kept cars as being better maintained mechanically.

4. Providing Poor Quality Photos

In the age of online listings, good photos are crucial. Poor quality photos can turn off potential buyers. Take clear, well-lit pictures from multiple angles, including the exterior, interior, and under the hood. Highlight all unique features or recent upgrades. This transparency builds trust and interest with potential buyers.

5. Not Being Honest About the Car’s Condition

Transparency is key when selling a car. Failing to disclose known issues can lead to unhappy buyers and even legal trouble. Be upfront about your car’s condition, including any past accidents or necessary repairs. Honest descriptions build credibility and trust with potential buyers.

6. Ignoring Scams and Safety Concerns

The process of selling a car can attract scammers. Be cautious of buyers who offer to pay more than the asking price, request personal information, or want to conduct transactions outside of secure methods. Always meet potential buyers in safe, public locations, and consider bringing a friend along. Insist and stand firm that payment must be made to you via a bank wire or certified funds. Verify payment can not be reversed or stopped before handing over the keys and title. Again, be sure to complete all required fields on the title with purchaser's information (based on driver license). Never leave assignment fields blank no matter what the reason given by buyer.

7. Overlooking the Importance of a Bill of Sale

A bill of sale protects both the buyer and the seller by providing a record of the transaction. It should include the sale date, vehicle identification number (VIN), make and model, sale price, and signatures from both parties. This document can prevent future disputes and is often required by state laws to complete the transfer of ownership. Always clearly denote, “Vehicle SOLD AS-IS” on the Bill of Sale and other transaction documents.

8. Not Knowing Your State’s DMV Requirements

Each state has different requirements for selling a car. Before you list your car for sale, familiarize yourself with your state’s laws regarding title transfer, emissions testing, and notification of sale. Completing these steps correctly ensures the buyer can register the car and that you’re no longer liable for it.

9. Failing to Remove Personal Items and Information

It’s easy to overlook personal belongings and information when selling a car. Double-check the car for personal items, and clear any stored data from the infotainment system, such as GPS locations, phone contacts, and garage door codes. Protecting your personal information is as important as securing the sale.

10. Underestimating the Power of Negotiation

Be prepared to negotiate. Many buyers expect some haggling, and starting with a slightly higher price can give you room to maneuver. However, be realistic and know your lowest acceptable price. Being flexible can help you close the deal faster but ensure you don’t settle for less than your car is worth. And always make the buyer present you with an offer if they think your list price is too high. Never answer the common question from buyers, “what’s your best price”? Instead, respond with, “if you like my car, but you hate my price, then make me a reasonable offer to consider.”

Best Way to Avoid Mistakes and Stress Selling Your Car

To completely avoid all of these and other common mistakes and make selling your car a smoother, stress-free and more profitable experience, explore using the consignment selling option.

RetailMyRide.com is a free online tool for sellers that uses a consignment approach where your car is sold through a network of retail dealerships (similar to hring a real estate agent to sell your house for you on commission). This often results in a much higher selling price compared to instant cash offers and even higher than selling your car yourself online. Consignment allows your vehicle to be marketed to potential buyers at a retail price rather than a wholesale or private party price. This process might take a little longer, generally 10-45 days, but can yield a higher payout because Retail My Ride’s network dealerships can leverage their sales expertise and customer base to get the best, true retail selling price for your car.

How Retail My Ride Works

Use Retail My Ride to Find & Connect with one of our trusted network dealerships specializing in selling your type of vehicle on consignment. Then, take your vehicle to the dealership to discuss their specific program requirements, and obtain a free, no-obligation appraisal. You can search by Zip code, City, County, State, and filter your search by vehicle type, including Cars, Trucks, SUVs, Vans, Classics, Exotics, Antiques, Custom/Mods, Wheelchair accessible, Commercial.

You can also request a free no-obligation quote and consultation by one of our consignment experts at Retail My Ride before being connected to your local network dealership.